Hours after SpaceX caught a Starship returning from orbit, the antitrust writer Matt Stoller told his 165,000 followers that the feat proved nothing special about Elon Musk. Musk answered him with one question Stoller’s theory cannot survive: if money and engineers are all it takes, why is Jeff Bezos’s Blue Origin still unable to launch reliably?
The exchange has drawn millions of views since the November 14 catch, and it is worth walking through, because Stoller’s argument is a common one on the left. It holds that great companies are just piles of capital, and that the people who build them are interchangeable. The record of the last quarter century of rocketry says otherwise.
“Not the skill his fanboys think it is”
On Saturday, November 14, SpaceX caught its Starship upper stage in the mechanical arms of its launch tower at Starbase, Texas, after 14 trips around the Earth. It was the first time a Starship returning from space had been caught by the launch tower’s arms.
RelatedThe World’s Chips Sit Within China’s Reach. Musk and Intel Are Building the Answer in Texas. →
That evening Stoller, who writes the BIG newsletter on monopoly power, posted his verdict on X:
“What SpaceX did today is the normal consequence of applying capital and engineering to any industry. You get better at it. Musk isn’t a genius, he’s just a guy who can get capital from Wall Street. Maybe that’s unique right now, but it’s not the skill his fanboys think it is.”
The post was viewed more than two million times and drew thousands of replies. One of the sharpest came on November 15 from the software entrepreneur David Heinemeier Hansson: “There are a million ‘capital allocators’, only one Musk.”

Musk’s reply
Musk weighed in later that day, in the thread beneath Hansson’s post. “Let’s take this gentleman’s argument at face value that anyone can throw money at rockets and get something like Starship, Falcon or Dragon,” he wrote.
“Perhaps he can explain to everyone how SpaceX is able to catch giant starships from orbit with chopsticks and deliver 85% of all Earth payload to orbit with Falcon, while Blue Origin, which started before SpaceX and was funded by the immensely wealthy Jeff Bezos, is not yet able to launch reliably?”
He added a second question aimed at the old-line contractors: “Also, why is it that Boeing and Lockheed received several times what SpaceX did from the government for development of their rockets and spacecraft, but the Boeing capsule is still not operational and ULA delivers less than 5% of SpaceX payload to orbit?” He signed off: “I am genuinely curious about these questions.” The 85% and 5% figures are Musk’s own. By November 18 his post had been viewed more than five million times.
Keep readingSpaceX Catches a Starship Coming Home From Orbit, a First in Spaceflight History →
The control group is Blue Origin
Musk’s point is the strongest one available, because Blue Origin is as close to a controlled experiment as business ever offers. It has the capital Stoller says is the secret ingredient, from one of the richest men in history. It has had more time. It hires from the same pool of aerospace engineers. It answers to the same laws of physics.
Here is where it stands. On May 28, its New Glenn rocket exploded on the launch pad at Cape Canaveral during a static fire test, a routine engine firing ahead of its fourth flight, which was to carry Amazon’s Leo internet satellites. Nobody was hurt. Bezos said it was “too early to know the root cause.” The blast destroyed the pad’s lightning tower and the transporter-erector that moves the rocket to the pad and raises it, and the cause has since been traced to the main oxygen valve on one of the booster’s BE-4 engines.
The three flights before that were mixed. The first, in January 2025, reached orbit but lost its booster. The second, in November 2025, launched twin NASA spacecraft toward Mars and landed its booster. The third, in April 2026, reflew that booster, but an upper-stage failure lost a customer’s satellite.
On November 4, ten days before Starship came home, Blue Origin CEO Dave Limp told employees in a memo that New Glenn’s return to flight would slip again, from December to January 2027, citing summer weather, flash flooding and the work of rebuilding the launch complex. So on the weekend SpaceX caught a ship from orbit, the rival bankrolled by Jeff Bezos was still rebuilding its launch pad.
The money came after the rockets worked
Stoller’s other claim, that Musk’s real talent is pulling money from Wall Street, gets the history backward. SpaceX’s first rocket, the small Falcon 1, failed three times: in March 2006 a fuel leak doomed it shortly after liftoff, in March 2007 the second stage went into a gyration, and in 2008 the first stage bumped the second stage at separation. Only on the fourth attempt, on September 28, 2008, did Falcon 1 become the first privately developed liquid-fueled rocket to reach orbit.
Less than three months later, on December 23, 2008, NASA announced it was buying space station cargo flights from SpaceX. “We’re looking at potentially 12 flights from SpaceX valued at $1.6 billion,” NASA’s Bill Gerstenmaier said at the time. The big contracts followed a working rocket. They did not produce one.
Nor is a heavy flow of capital rare. By Musk’s account, Boeing and Lockheed received several times SpaceX’s government development money, and his question about their results stands unanswered. Money is the most abundant ingredient in American aerospace. What has been scarce is a company that will fly, fail, fix the problem and fly again on a schedule measured in weeks.
What Stoller gets right, and wrong
There is a fair version of Stoller’s point. No one builds rockets alone, and capital matters. But “apply capital and engineering and you get better” is a description of what is supposed to happen, not what does happen. Blue Origin applied both for longer and is still waiting to launch again. The Boeing capsule Musk mentioned is, by his account, still not operational.
The difference between those outcomes is not the size of the checkbook. It is judgment: which risks to take, how fast to iterate, when to blow up a design and start over, and how to build a team that can catch a spaceship with a pair of steel arms. Call it genius or call it something else, but it is a skill, and the market has been unable to buy it anywhere else.
Capital is everywhere in the space business; the only thing nobody else has managed to buy is what Elon Musk brings to it.
Next story →Musk at DealBook: Zelensky Is ‘Not Always Truthful’ About Starlink, and Russia Is the AggressorAt the DealBook Summit, Musk said Zelensky is lying about Starshield, called Russia the aggressor, and said Ukraine’s lines would have collapsed without Starlink.


