Photo-Illustration: by The Cut; Photos: Getty Images
For more than 20 years, author Dara Fleischer’s life looked incredible. She had a thriving career in fashion (first in magazines, and later at retailers such as the RealReal), an incredible wardrobe, a devoted husband, and eventually young twins. But she had a secret: Her life was buckling under the weight of a runaway shopping addiction. She hid her debt, stashed designer clothes in garbage bags at the back of her closet, and told herself she’d rein in her habits — but then more packages would arrive, and the spiral continued.
Compulsive shopping or spending disorder, also known as oniomania (from the ancient Greek word meaning “to buy”), is defined as “an overpowering, uncontrollable, chronic, and repetitive urge to shop and spend.” Despite frequent appearances in pop culture, real-life shopaholics are not well understood by the mental-health community, and many of them struggle to stick with treatment programs (which usually include therapy, group support, and medication). “There’s so much shame, guilt, anxiety, and constant fear about paying bills,” Fleischer says. “I’m sure people will read this and think, Well, how stupid are you? Why couldn’t you just stop buying things? But that’s part of the disease and the compulsion.”
Two years ago, Fleischer came clean to her family, started therapy, liquidated her retirement savings to pay off her debt, and committed herself to recovery. She has since written a memoir about her experience, At My Limit, and started a podcast where she interviews other recovering compulsive shoppers. Below, she shares the moment she knew she had to stop, her advice to fellow problem shoppers, and why she’s still tempted by the retail marketing traps she helped build.
How did your shopping habits begin?
I hate saying that fashion is in my DNA, because my mother is also a shopaholic and I love her dearly, but it’s true. My parents worked hard, and they instilled good values, but my mom always spent too much, and I learned from her. I worked hard for my money, and I spent it all on clothes. Growing up, shopping was really our love language. I was a latchkey kid, so I was given things — it was my parents’ way of showing their love because they weren’t around. Later on, I worked in fashion, so it was normalized to shop all the time. When I hit rock bottom, I had $124 in my bank account and owed more than $50,000 on my credit cards and “buy now, pay later” platforms.
How did you get into the fashion industry?
I’m from Montreal, and I always knew that I wanted to live in New York. I moved there in 1994, as soon as I graduated from college in Toronto. I remember going to Bleecker Street and buying Converse high-tops, one pink, one purple. Fashion put me in a kind of trance.
I worked for a bunch of websites and publications. I also started my own blog, Fashion Junkie. I would go to Barneys, Bergdorf, Bloomingdale’s, and other stores and take pictures of myself in different outfits and then ask people what I should buy. Looking back, it was kind of a cry for help. But at the time, I didn’t realize I was a compulsive shopper. I just thought it was fun. Then, when I was about 33, I moved back to Toronto to help launch a shopping magazine called Lou Lou. I became the shopping editor, and it was my dream job. I literally traveled the world to write shopping guides and interview designers and store owners. I was exposed to so much fashion and I got industry discounts, which, of course, I graciously accepted. I had events to go to and meetings and whatnot — I used any excuse to buy new things.
When did you start to overspend and get into debt?
I was always overspending, but it didn’t get really out of control until I got my first credit card in my early 30s, in the early 2000s. Before I knew it, I owed $30,000 in credit card debt. Then I got engaged to my now-husband, who lived back in New York. He didn’t know I had the debt. So before I got married in 2005, I told myself that I would pay it all off. I took out a low-interest loan from a bank, and I paid it down before our wedding.
How did you hide your shopping from your husband?
The irony is that we are complete opposites when it comes to money. He was an investment banker. He’s frugal, he saves, he’s always dealing with money and spreadsheets. And I’m the irresponsible, selfish asshole gallivanting around the city, living paycheck to paycheck. When we got married, I moved back to New York from Toronto, and in 2009 we had twins. For the next ten years, I worked and consulted for a number of different fashion and beauty brands, like the RealReal and Sephora. I also worked at Ventes Privées, a flash-sale website. My job was business development, so I was constantly pitching luxury brands and retailers to get them to sell their excess clothing and accessories on our site.
At one point, the company hired a consultant and she told everyone, “You have to dress the part.” Of course, we weren’t given a clothing allowance. It was just good vibes and my own credit card. And I didn’t bat an eye. I would spend $1,300 at Bergdorf on leather pants and whatever leather jacket I saw. It felt normal. I was surrounded by people who had impeccable taste and a lot more money than me. And I always felt like I needed to keep up with the Joneses, to my detriment. I was making decent money, so I’d be able to pay down my debt for a while, and then it would creep up again. Pretty soon, it was another $40,000 on my credit card. And that’s when buy now, pay later came into the mix. So I owed tons of money on Klarna, Afterpay, Affirm … all of them.
When things got really bad, what did that look like?
Right before COVID, I was laid off from my job. Then the pandemic hit, and things just spiraled. I was so depressed and stressed that I kept buying more clothing. Every day, I’d have packages coming from Intermix or Neiman Marcus or Shopbop. I was hiding things from my husband. I would tell my doorman to turn off notifications for any incoming packages. I had so much shit everywhere. I had piles of clothing in garbage bags. I would stash things in filing cabinets and the laundry bin and my kids’ closets. We had to get extra closet units from Ikea. In a New York apartment, there’s only so much you can hide. It was so embarrassing. My husband did not like it. He’d be like, “We have to clean this up. We can’t live like this anymore.” He knew I had a shopping problem, but he didn’t quite understand how bad it was or how to help me. So he avoided it, just like I did.
Then, unfortunately, my husband lost his job too. At one point, we were both unemployed, and I still had packages coming. I was consigning stuff to the RealReal, but there was no way I could make enough to pay off my debt, especially since I was still shopping. Fortunately, my husband wasn’t unemployed for long. That’s when we decided to relocate to Austin, Texas. I was able to get a new job, too, but I was working remotely and just shopping all day online. Struggling with shopping addiction in the digital age, especially with frictionless payment — it just ruined me. I was stacking eight or ten payment plans at once. It was horrible.
When did you realize you had a problem and needed to stop?
Leaving New York was a really hard adjustment. I was lonely and anxious and sort of in shock. Now I know it was a really important part of my recovery, but at the time, my shopping got even more out of control. Finally, I just couldn’t do it anymore. I got laid off again, and there I was, $50,000 in debt with no job. I was totally fucked. And I was tired of the lies. It was affecting my relationship with my husband and kids. How could I be a role model for my teenage twins? My son would walk into my closet and say, “You have a college fund’s worth of Golden Goose shoes in here.” And I hadn’t realized he’d noticed. It really bothered him. It still does.
The only way I could stop the bleeding was to wipe out my retirement fund, my 401(k). Fortunately, it had about $54,000 in it because my husband helped me set it up and contribute to it. So I liquidated most of it and paid off my debt. After that, I told him the truth — the full extent of my addiction — because I was so sick of dealing with the shame, the anxiety, and guilt.
How did he react?
He was obviously very upset with me. But I told him that I wanted to get better, not just for myself, but for our family. I feel very lucky, but I also feel like such an asshole because my husband is such a hard worker. He didn’t divorce me, and I’m still amazed that he didn’t, because if I were in his shoes, I would’ve been kicked to the curb many moons ago. He’s a wonderful person. He obviously loves me a lot. He really wanted to help me, and he told me that I needed to go into therapy. In order to save the marriage, I had to stop shopping and get help. So I did.
I found a good therapist, and that really saved me. He pushed me to try Debtors Anonymous and put me on OCD medication. I don’t know if there’s one singular thing that really worked. I wish there were a magic pill that could get rid of addiction and overspending, but there isn’t. At the end of the day, you have to want to change. For me, it was being in so much debt, on the brink of divorce, and really upsetting my kids. Anytime I had a package at the door, my son didn’t want to talk to me. I wanted to stop.
What did recovery look like for you?
I had to take accountability. It’s the reason that I wrote this book. If I can help just one other person who’s struggling with this, then it will have been worth it. I had to cut up all but one of my credit cards. I had a Saks card, a Neiman Marcus card, a Bloomingdale’s card, a Bergdorf card. I used Venmo, PayPal, and then of course all the buy now, pay laters.
I’ve since stayed out of debt. I haven’t used buy now, pay later in two years, and I never will again. I closed every single account. It’s devastating to look back in my history and see what I spent. I still have urges. There are triggers, like Black Friday and hearing about a limited-edition drop of something I love. I’m working on that. I recently bought a pair of limited-edition cowboy boots and then was like, “What am I doing?” I returned them. It took me a while to stop chasing the dopamine hit, the high of the buy, but I’m not perfect. I still make mistakes. I’ll still shop, but it’s rare. Before, I was buying my fantasy self. I didn’t need anything. I had to ask myself, “Why do I continue to buy these things, many of which I’ve never worn? They’re sitting in my closet with tags attached.” And part of the problem with being so deep in a compulsive shopping addiction is you’re in the fog of vagueness. You don’t really realize what you’re doing. Your moral compass just flies out the window.
How did your parents react when you told them?
I think my parents always knew that I had a shopping problem, but not how out of control it was. Even my mother was pretty horrified. I mean, she’s a shopaholic herself, but not to the same degree as me. When my mother found out that I have 40 pairs of designer cowboy boots from the same brand, she was just mortified. That’s just horrible, selfish. My father sadly suffers from dementia, and that’s another reason why I had to change. What if, God forbid, I’m in the same situation as my mother one day, and I have to handle all our family’s bills and my shopping is still out of hand?
When you told your husband, were their ramifications in terms of your shared finances? How have you structured your accounts since you told him the truth?
He had to set up guardrails. He pays all the bills. We do share a joint Amex, and I only use it on essentials like groceries. He takes care of the savings accounts too, fortunately. I don’t have access to our kids’ college funds, which I understand. It’s going to take a while for him to trust me. Being honest has definitely improved our relationship, but it’s tough.
How are you doing now?
It’s still a daily struggle. It’s really hard and it does damage relationships. Thankfully, my recovery definitely healed my relationship with my husband. Things got much better. But it’s something that I work on every single day.
A big part of recovery was unsubscribing from every single email. You have to unsubscribe from texts and ask any sales associate that reaches out to take you off their list. I also use a Brick, to block apps and retailer sites and social media. Social media is kryptonite. I can’t spend any time on it. But if you don’t know something’s there, you’re not going to crave it.
Everyone laughs at shopping addictions. They shrug it off because they think it’s not harmful, like a substance addiction — “Oh, at least you’re not addicted to fentanyl.” But it does affect you physically and emotionally. It’s caused me a great deal of pain, because I did it to myself. I worked for the retail industry. I know all the tricks. We all know it’s bullshit. And yet I still felt prey to all the retail marketing traps.
Were there any specific parts of treatment that helped the most?
Two years ago, I joined a program called the Shopping Shift, founded by Hannah Blass in Vancouver. She was a former shopaholic herself, and she started this virtual private community to help other shoppers like me. What I like about it is that she incorporates your personal style into the program. You audit your closet, do no-buys, and try to retrain your brain. Fashion is still a big part of my identity, so that’s been good for me to incorporate it into my recovery. Through that program, I am now the no-buy lead, so I get to help other people, and that’s really therapeutic.
Debtors Anonymous wasn’t quite right for me, but I’m glad I tried it. It’s very spiritual, and I’m not a religious person. But I didn’t want to give up on it, so I attended Zooms and met lovely people I could relate to. It feels good to share with people who understand what you’re going through. And it doesn’t matter if they’re not in debt over luxury cowboy boots — some people focus on electronics or they shop too much on Amazon. It was helpful to hear other people’s stories in a nonjudgmental space.
Any other advice for someone who’s struggling with this?
You have to take it day by day. It’s corny, but it’s true. If you just say to yourself, “I’m not going to shop for 24 hours and I’ll be okay,” you can do it. I also think about how I want to be remembered. Do I want to be remembered for being in debt, for having a hundred pairs of Golden Goose shoes? Do I want my children to be stuck with this mess when I die? No.
Email your money conundrums to mytwocents@nymag.com (and read our submission terms here.)
