Putin Didn’t Get His Yalta, but He’s Happy Nonetheless

Putin Didn’t Get His Yalta, but He’s Happy Nonetheless

Two and a half years ago, I wrote about how desperately Russian President Vladimir Putin wanted another Yalta—a new summit of the world’s three most powerful leaders, like the historic meeting in Crimea in 1945 between Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin. He needed to return to the world stage as a global player and put an end to the image of himself as a pariah that had emerged after his invasion of Ukraine.

Here’s my latest piece for the Atlantic Council’s Dispatches.

Of course, Thursday’s summit in Shenzhen with Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump is not exactly the Yalta Putin had dreamed of. But he is happy nonetheless.

His greatest success is the video we have all seen: Trump walking toward Putin and saying, “He’s my friend.”

Why does this matter? Because it sends an incredibly powerful message to the entire Russian elite: no matter what Putin does, he gets away with it. He is still the smartest, most experienced, and simply most brilliant politician in Russia. There is no alternative to him. Even after nearly five years of war against Ukraine, he is not an international pariah. On the contrary, he is a friend of the US president.

And this is despite the fact that Putin demonstratively rejects every proposal for a peace settlement. He comes up with ridiculous excuses while flattering Trump by repeatedly blaming former President Joe Biden for supposedly starting the war in Ukraine and accusing Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy of not wanting peace.

Xi also made it clear that the current arrangement is by no means a replica of the Yalta trio of Stalin, Roosevelt, and Churchill. During the group photo, Xi rather imperiously directed Putin to his place—not next to Xi himself, but next to the Chinese first lady.

In other words, Putin is clearly China’s junior partner. He was reminded of this repeatedly throughout the visit.

The final declaration issued after the trilateral summit is a truly remarkable document. It almost seems as though it was written specifically for the Russian president. It contains four points, each of particular importance to him. For the rest of the world, they amount to little more than vague generalities. For Putin, however, each of them matters enormously.

First, the declaration states that the leaders of the three countries agree that the International Criminal Court (ICC) “must not abuse [its] jurisdiction.” Who really cares about this? Putin, of course. The ICC has issued an arrest warrant for him.

The next point declares that there can be no winners in a nuclear war. Who is this directed at? Again, Putin. For several years, Russian propaganda has been relentlessly arguing that Russia can and should win a nuclear war, and that if Russia launches a nuclear strike against Europe, the Americans will not intervene.

With this declaration, Trump seems almost to be pleading with Putin: Please, don’t launch a nuclear strike. In return, we won’t recognize the ICC or the arrest warrant against you.

The third point concerns everyone, but Putin in particular. It says that the global flow of oil and petroleum products should not be obstructed.

Oil matters to everyone, but for Putin, oil exports are absolutely critical to his survival. In January of this year, when oil prices were low, the Russian economy was on the verge of collapse. Then Trump started the war in Iran, oil prices skyrocketed, and the Russian economy recovered.

So, for his own political survival, Putin desperately needs Trump not to impose devastating sanctions on Russian oil exports. By refraining from doing so, Trump effectively guarantees Putin’s survival.

Finally, the declaration expresses dissatisfaction with the United Nations. Here, all three leaders are largely on the same page. But it is Putin who has faced the harshest condemnation from the UN General Assembly. Its resolutions condemning Russia’s war against Ukraine have been far more forceful than any criticism directed at Trump or Xi by the United Nations.

Incidentally, the war in Ukraine is not mentioned in the declaration at all.

Perhaps the most interesting part of all this is that, for Putin, this reception is undoubtedly a triumph, even if Xi did not treat him with quite the respect he might have wished for. But that does not mean Putin is now prepared to make any commitments in return.

Quite the opposite. Despite what Trump has said, Putin has absolutely no intention of making peace with Ukraine. Nor does he intend to make any concessions to Trump.

In Putin’s eyes, Trump has been a lame duck for quite some time—long before the midterm elections. He sees no reason to compromise with a leader who, sooner or later, will leave the White House and be replaced by someone else.

According to Putin’s logic, there is simply no point in negotiating seriously with any US administration.

But taking historic photographs that look great on Russian propaganda shows and will fit perfectly into Putin’s future history textbooks?

That’s a different matter entirely. That suits Putin just fine.

Thanks for reading The Last Pioneer! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Share

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *