The Premier League’s Key Match Incidents (KMI) Panel has backed the decision not to send off Leeds United defender Jayden Bogle for his challenge on Tottenham Hotspur forward Mathys Tel.
The incident occurred in the 34th minute of the Premier League encounter between the two clubs, when Bogle caught Tel on the back of his ankle.
Despite the nature of the contact, the referee decided against showing the Leeds defender a red card, with VAR also declining to intervene.
The challenge subsequently came under scrutiny from the independent KMI Panel, which reviews major refereeing decisions across every round of Premier League fixtures.
In its assessment of Match Round 10, the panel voted 3-2 in favour of the original decision, concluding that the tackle did not meet the threshold for serious foul play.
However, the narrow margin reflected disagreement among the five members over the severity of Bogle’s challenge.
The majority considered the contact reckless but felt it lacked the speed, force or intensity required to justify a dismissal.
According to the panel’s explanation, Bogle had attempted to challenge for the ball with his right leg before his left leg landed on the back of Tel’s ankle.
Although the incident was considered a clear foul, three members concluded that the defender’s actions warranted a lesser punishment.
The remaining two panellists disagreed, believing the challenge was sufficiently dangerous to merit a straight red card.
The panel also supported VAR’s decision not to recommend an on-field review by the same 3-2 margin.
Its reasoning was that the referee’s judgement did not constitute a clear and obvious error, given the majority’s interpretation of the challenge.
The findings underline the distinction between reckless tackles and serious foul play under the Laws of the Game.
Reckless challenges generally warrant a yellow card, while tackles involving excessive force or endangering an opponent’s safety can result in dismissal.
The Bogle incident was not the only controversial decision examined from the Leeds-Tottenham encounter.
An earlier penalty appeal against Tottenham midfielder Fernandes, following a possible handball in the fourth minute, was also reviewed.
On that occasion, the panel unanimously supported the decision not to award Leeds a penalty.
Although Fernandes had leaned towards the ball, the contact occurred in an area of the arm that the panel considered non-punishable.
The Premier League’s latest report forms part of its efforts to improve transparency around refereeing decisions.
Across Match Round 10, the panel assessed 27 key on-field decisions and found that 78 per cent had been correct.