What do you do when you meet a cute guy at the vet, have a great conversation, exchange a few flirtatious smiles, and then he simply says goodbye and walks away?
That’s the question a woman posted in a Facebook group this week. She was fed up with dating apps, and for a moment, it seemed like romance might finally happen the old-fashioned way.
While they waited for their appointments, he showed her pictures of his dogs, mentioned that he lived alone now that his children had moved out, and they exchanged smiles. Then his turn came. When he came out, he smiled, said goodbye and walked away.
And there she was, left with a vomiting dog and the feeling that life had just thrown up the love of her life.
But if she was hoping for a little encouragement from the Facebook group, she was in for a disappointment. The comments quickly turned into a full-blown interrogation. “He’s probably not single.” “He was just being friendly.” And then came the final verdict: “If he wanted to, he would have made a move.”
Personally, I have no idea whether that man was single or what was going through his mind. Maybe he has a girlfriend. Maybe he just wasn’t interested in her.
But the idea that “if he wanted to, he would have made a move” sounds to me like a piece of dating advice passed down through generations along with Grandma’s fine china. It might have made sense once, but times have changed.
These days, a man can be genuinely interested, flash a charming smile and still somehow lose the ability to make a move when the woman he likes isn’t on the other side of a screen.
Research suggests that dating apps have contributed to a decline in people approaching potential partners in person. Men have acknowledged that rejection feels less painful when they’re hiding behind a screen. They can approach dozens of women, get turned down and simply move on.
Not long after my divorce, I experienced this firsthand. I went with some friends to a singles party for divorced people looking for love again. The next day, a man who had spotted me at the party and found me attractive sent me a message on Facebook.
He hadn’t approached me at the party itself. We’d been in the same room, breathing the same air, yet somehow, to say hello, he first had to go home and log on to the internet.
I have to admit, I find that logic a little strange. Sure, approaching someone in person means risking rejection face-to-face. But at least the embarrassment is fleeting, with no record left behind. In your inbox, on the other hand, you can revisit that “humiliation” over and over again.
Still, as someone dating after divorce, I can understand the hesitation. Once you’re over 40, taking a chance feels a lot riskier. When you exchange glances with someone, you’re not just wondering whether they’re single. You’re also wondering if there’s a spouse, children, a cat, a dog or a shared mortgage in the picture. Before letting yourself feel butterflies, you’d almost rather ask to see official proof of their marital status.
And yet, every so often, life surprises you and reminds you that meeting someone the old-fashioned way is still possible. Since my divorce, men have approached me on the street in situations that felt like the perfect opening scene of a romantic television series.
I appreciated their initiative, but I also realized that men have a slight advantage here. A woman without a wedding ring at least offers some reason for optimism. A man without a wedding ring might simply be a married man who doesn’t like jewelry.
And that’s why, for me at least, the uncertainty is enough to put me off flirting altogether. Even if I spot a gorgeous man at the supermarket and we exchange glances across the dairy aisle, I’ll think twice before giving him a smile that might be mistaken for romantic interest.
And if I do accidentally flash him a flirtatious smile? I’ll probably leave the eggs behind and make a quick escape.
In an interview I did with Israeli actor Yoni Zicholtz, he told me he isn’t a fan of dating apps and is convinced he’ll meet the love of his life by chance, perhaps “while reaching for a melon or half a watermelon at Tiv Ta’am,” an Israeli supermarket chain.
I smiled because I really want to believe you can still pop out to buy some fruit and come home with the beginnings of a love story.
The trouble is, with a watermelon, you can tell right away if it’s only half. With a man, it’s much harder to know whether he’s already part of a couple.
