The Ultimate Thanksgiving Game Plan, From Turkey Shopping To Oven Timing

Thanksgiving may not technically arrive until next Thursday, November 26, but the holiday starts long before then. Between shopping, planning, cooking, and—oh, what else?—eating, there’s plenty to do. Luckily, Delish’s team of trained cooks and culinary experts is here to help.

Below, you’ll find our ultimate guide to Thanksgiving: what to shop for and when, what size turkey to buy and how to cook it, menu ideas for every type of gathering, and quick tips from our Test Kitchen editors. Grab a pen and paper, because there’s a lot to gobble up…

Text graphic with the phrase "Be An Early Bird" highlighted in large font, titled "SECTION 1" at the top.
A roasted turkey on a platter with drumsticks, set against a light background.

Don’t shop for most perishable items, like produce and dairy, until Thanksgiving week. But you can stock up now on plenty of shelf-stable or order-ahead essentials, including wine, stock, serving supplies, and baking ingredients. One exception for perishable goods: butter. Unopened butter will keep in the fridge for weeks—and if you’re anything like us, Thanksgiving involves a lot of butter.

If you’re serving a fresh turkey, buy it or arrange to pick it up at least a day or two before the holiday. That gives you time to brine or season it.

Frozen turkeys need 24 hours in the refrigerator for every 4 pounds to thaw. A 12-pound bird, for example, will need three days. Factor that into your pickup plans—or, if you have room in your freezer, buy your turkey now.

Test Kitchen Tip: Choosing Your Cheese Board

Smiling woman with curly hair and hoop earrings against a light background.

A good cheese board is all about variety. Opt for a mix of soft, semi-firm, and hard cheeses in approachable varieties like Gruyère, cheddar, and Parmigiano-Reggiano. Balance those familiar flavors with a few unexpected touches: a fresh herb coating can make goat cheese more inviting, while a jam-filled center on a wheel of brie adds a playful pop. Finish with colorful fruit, olives, and crackers, and for extra inspiration—read more below.

Read More

A cartoon representation of a whole turkey on a brown background.
Section 2: Feed Your Flock in bold, stylized typography on a maroon background.

You know when to buy your bird, but what size should you get? It’s all about finding the sweet spot. Conventional wisdom says to plan on 1 pound per person, but that feels a little skimpy to us. Bumping it up to 1 1/2 pounds per guest might be overdoing it, so we landed on 1 1/4 pounds of turkey per person as the perfect balance.

For big groups, consider cooking two smaller turkeys instead of one 20-pound monster.

Wondering where to get your bird? There’s nothing wrong with a supermarket turkey, but you can also order one from D’Artagnan, ButcherBox, Harry & David, and more. For deals on the rest of the meal, retailers like Target, Walmart, Costco, and Sam’s Club offer Thanksgiving meals for as little as $4 per person.

Test Kitchen Tip: Trust The Truss

Smiling person in a light blazer with a navy shirt, set against a light background in a circular frame.

You might think trussing a turkey is just for show, but there are a couple of culinary benefits, too. It makes the turkey more compact, so all the meat cooks more evenly and helps prevent the dreaded dry turkey breast. Trussing a turkey can also help you achieve a crisp, golden-brown skin. Below, we’ll break it all down for you so you can achieve a picture-perfect, Hallmark bird. And don’t worry: Trussing is ultimately as easy as tying a knot.

Read More

Section 3: Don't Just Wing It
A roasted turkey with a meat thermometer reading 165°F and a baster resting on top.
Google

Add Delish as a preferred source in your Google search results.

Use your Google account to add this to your settings.

Whether you’re cooking the whole feast or bringing a dish to a potluck, a little menu planning now can save you a last-minute dash to the grocery store later. We’ve got recipes for every course, from traditional favorites like green bean casserole to creative crowd-pleasers (say it with us: Pumpkin Spice Hot Honey Brie Bites), so there’s something for every table.

Test Kitchen Tip: Master Your Mashed Potatoes

Smiling person with long hair and earrings in a circular frame with an orange border.

Mashed potatoes are made from simple ingredients, but they’re surprisingly easy to mess up. To make the ultimate mashed potatoes, use both starchy and all-purpose potatoes, cut them into pieces before boiling, and salt the water. Pushing the potatoes through a ricer keeps them extra light, and mixing in pre-warmed dairy helps them stay fluffy and warm until you serve them. Need step-by-step instructions? Read more below.

Read More

A stylized illustration of a chicken drumstick with a blue bone tip against a light beige background.
Get A Leg Up, Section 4, bold text on a maroon background

Good news: You’re already getting ahead by reading this guide! You can also make some dishes now and freeze them for Thanksgiving. First, give your freezer a good clean-out, then stock it with a few classics:

  • Make gravy without the drippings a few weeks ahead and freeze it. Reheat it after the turkey is done, then stir in some drippings.
  • Pie crust is a great make-ahead project. Transfer it from the freezer to the refrigerator the day before you plan to use it.
  • Homemade stock is nice to have on hand, though store-bought works, too. Freeze it, then thaw it overnight to use in casseroles or stuffing.

Test Kitchen Tip: Perfect Your Pumpkin Pie

Smiling woman with long dark hair and earrings, wearing a colorful sweater, against a light background in a circular frame.

Pumpkin pie is a Thanksgiving staple, so if you’ve been put on pie duty, you’ll want to bring a winner. Luckily, a few easy upgrades can take your pie from good to great. From adding heavy cream to a splash of bourbon, I’ll help you throw a little subtle magic into your pie, making folks wonder what that secret ingredient is. Any type of caramelization or caramel will also take things to the next level. Read more for details!

Read More

Section 5: Carve Out Oven Space
Oven with a roasted chicken on a plate inside.

One of Thanksgiving’s biggest challenges is choreographing the oven: getting every dish in and out so it’s hot (or, okay, at least warm) by dinnertime. There’s only so much room, and different dishes may need different oven temperatures.

The easiest way to sort it out is to write everything down. Note how long each dish needs to cook and at what temperature, then map it all out on a timeline for the day. Pro tip: Don’t be afraid to pull the turkey an hour or two before dinner to make room for the remaining dishes. Just keep it hot at 140° or above while it waits. Here’s an example timeline from my own archives:

Thanksgiving meal preparation timeline with cooking times and tasks for turkey, sides, and serving.

Roasted turkey on a rack with steam rising, in a simple and minimalist style.
Section 6: Gobble It Up

Between cooking, cleaning, and taking care of your guests, don’t forget one important thing: Have fun! Thanksgiving isn’t about serving a picture-perfect golden-brown bird or the fluffiest mashed potatoes. It’s about enjoying the people around your table and filling up however you see fit—whether that means another scoop of buttery stuffing or a really good conversation. Hopefully, you get a little bit of both.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *