Slower Birr Depreciation Masks Deeper Problems in Ethiopia

Slower Birr Depreciation Masks Deeper Problems in Ethiopia

Association warns parallel-market premium and bank backlog point to reform gaps despite narrower official spreads

The Ethiopian Economics Association (EEA) has cautioned that slower depreciation and narrower bank quotation spreads do not signal a properly functioning foreign exchange market, citing a widening parallel-market gap and persistent access constraints as evidence that the 2024 reform’s gains remain incomplete.

In its Quarterly Macroeconomic Update, the EEA warned that the combination of slower depreciation and narrower bank quotation spreads should not be interpreted, in isolation, as evidence of exchange-rate equilibrium, effective market clearing or a fully functioning foreign exchange market.

The association’s principal concern is the growing divergence between the official and parallel markets. The premium widened from ETB 19.05 (12.0 percent) on July 1 to ETB 26.10 (16.2 percent) on September 30, an increase of ETB 7.05 that reversed the narrowing recorded in the same quarter a year earlier.

The EEA attributed the widening to the parallel rate rising faster than the official rate from mid-August onward. It linked the gap to foreign exchange restrictions, limited financial market depth, an illiquid interbank market, and bank backlogs estimated at approximately 1.4 billion US dollars at the end of April 2026, the latest figure cited in the report and several months older than the quarter under review.

Alternative channels continue to offer rates well above the official benchmark of about ETB 160.90 per US dollar. On September 30, the Commercial Bank of Ethiopia reportedly offered a 7.875 percent incentive on its selling rate for remittances received through its digital applications, while Rooha Forex Bureau quoted a cash buying rate of ETB 183.03 and a selling rate of ETB 186.69 per dollar.

That divergence contrasts with developments within the official market, where commercial bank quotations converged markedly. The buying-rate spread narrowed from ETB 5.31 to ETB 2.11, while the selling-rate spread fell from ETB 5.41 to ETB 2.15, with all 26 reporting banks applying an identical 2 percent margin.

The association cautioned, however, that this convergence “does not necessarily establish stronger competition or improved market liquidity.” It suggested the uniformity may reflect banks anchoring to a common market signal rather than genuine price discovery. A uniform quoted spread, it added, does not imply identical transaction margins or equal access to foreign exchange across institutions.

A similar gap between appearance and substance emerges in the official exchange rate itself. The birr depreciated by 1.2 percent in the quarter, from ETB 158.95 to ETB 160.90 per US dollar, among the slowest rates of depreciation since the July 2024 reform and well below the 8.1 percent recorded in the same quarter a year earlier.

Yet the EEA warned that this should not be read as equilibrium. The 1.72 birr one-day adjustment on August 14 demonstrated that extended periods of limited daily variation can still give way to discrete moves. Greater alignment in commercial bank quotations, the report noted, did not translate into comparable convergence between official and parallel-market rates.

The report also placed the quarter in historical context. The July 2024 reform itself produced a one-day depreciation of 31.3 percent, from ETB 57.49 to ETB 75.48 per US dollar, followed by a further 58.0 percent depreciation over the remainder of that quarter. Measured over the twelve months to September 30, 2026, the currency weakened by 9.9 percent, from ETB 146.42 per dollar a year earlier.

Effective exchange rate trends reinforce the case for caution on competitiveness. The Real Effective Exchange Rate Index fell 0.66 percent in the quarter, extending its year-on-year decline to 11.2 percent, though the pace of real depreciation had moderated from 7.9 percent in the fourth quarter of FY2024/25.

The Nominal Effective Exchange Rate Index, by contrast, appreciated 3.75 percent to 16.6, the largest quarterly appreciation in the four quarters examined, but remained about 2.9 percent below its year-earlier level. The EEA stressed that translating real depreciation into stronger exports depends on productive capacity, access to imported inputs, infrastructure, trade logistics, and firms’ ability to respond to relative prices.

Commodity prices added further pressure. Gold averaged 4,268 US dollars per troy ounce, up 23.4 percent year-on-year, while Arabica coffee averaged 7.71 US dollars per kilogram, down 3.9 percent. Crude oil and wheat rose 40.5 percent and 41 percent respectively, raising import costs and inflationary pressure, while urea fell 18.3 percent and diammonium phosphate (DAP) rose 2.8 percent.

The report set out seven prioritized policy actions, including clearing foreign exchange backlogs and improving formal-channel access.

The EEA Noted that sustaining the reform’s benefits will require tangible improvements in foreign exchange availability, market liquidity, transparency, and structural competitiveness. A slower rate of depreciation alone, it said, will not be sufficient.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *