Should Vietnam ban children aged 16 and under from using smartphones?



Should Vietnam ban children aged 16 and under from using smartphones?


Parents should encourage their children to take part in extracurricular activities such as football, swimming, badminton, cycling, and running during the summer instead of spending time on smartphones. Photo: Quang Dinh / Tuoi Tre



They said families, schools, regulators, and technology companies should share responsibility for ensuring children use digital devices safely and appropriately.

During a recent National Assembly discussion, lawmaker Pham Van Hoa of Dong Thap Province in southern Vietnam, proposed that the government study a ban on smartphone use by children aged 16 and under.

Lawyer Dang Van Cuong, a member of the executive committee of the Vietnam Association for the Protection of Child Rights, said the proposal stemmed from legitimate concerns about the impact of the digital environment on children’s physical, intellectual, and personal development.

However, he said the issue should be approached scientifically and comprehensively, taking into account both the benefits and risks of smart devices rather than focusing solely on their negative effects.

Smartphones are no longer merely communication or entertainment devices, but also tools for accessing knowledge, learning, research, creativity, and social interaction, he said.

An outright ban could unintentionally restrict children’s rights to access information, education, recreation, and participation in social life.

Cuong cited results from the 2024 Voice of Vietnamese Children survey, which found that 83.9 percent of participating children used smartphones, 86.1 percent used social media, and nearly 27 percent spent up to five hours a day on their phones.

He stressed the need to distinguish between the harm caused by excessive or inappropriate smartphone use and the technology itself.

The impact depends on children’s ages, screen time, the content they access, their reasons for using devices, family environments, and their ability to regulate their behavior.

Should Vietnam ban children aged 16 and under from using smartphones? - Ảnh 1.

Dr. Dang Van Cuong, a member of the executive committee of the Vietnam Association for the Protection of Child Rights. Photo: Supplied

Age-based restrictions instead of blanket ban

Cuong said Vietnam should consider a multi-layered regulatory framework instead of immediately opting for an outright ban.

Restrictions should vary according to children’s ages and levels of maturity, with younger children subject to closer supervision. The same rules should not apply to five-year-olds, 10-year-olds, and 15-year-olds.

Authorities should also consider age-appropriate limits on screen time, content, and conditions of use.

Schools should establish clear rules on smartphone use, potentially restricting or banning devices during lessons, tests and activities requiring concentration while allowing exceptions for educational, medical or emergency purposes.

Digital platforms should be required to develop age-verification tools, content filters, and measures to protect children’s data.

Families also have a major role in supervising and educating children. Parents should not simply hand their children smartphones for entertainment and leave schools and society to take responsibility for managing their use.

Families should establish rules on device use, set time limits, discourage phone use during meals and before bedtime, and encourage sports and face-to-face interaction.

Children should also receive digital literacy education, including skills to identify misinformation, prevent online bullying, avoid scams and abuse, and protect personal data.

The ultimate goal should not simply be to reduce children’s screen time, but to help them use technology intelligently, responsibly and safely, Cuong said.

He added that an outright ban should only be considered after other management and control measures had been shown to be impractical or ineffective, describing prohibition as a last resort rather than the first option.

Lawmaker says blanket ban would be difficult to enforce

National Assembly deputy Trinh Thi Tu Anh, representing Lam Dong Province in the Central Highlands, also opposed an outright prohibition on smartphones for children aged 16 and under.

However, she emphasized the need to distinguish between devices and how they are used. The risks mainly stem from the content, applications, usage patterns, and duration of use, rather than the phones themselves.

Banning all devices to prevent certain risky behaviors would impose restrictions far broader than necessary to achieve the intended protection, she said.

Smartphones also serve as tools for learning, information searches, communication with family members, and access to essential services amid Vietnam’s ongoing digital transformation.

Children need digital skills to adapt to the future workplace and society. A generation of digital citizens cannot be educated by completely separating them from digital technology, she added.

Tu Anh also questioned the feasibility of enforcing such a ban, noting that it would be difficult to determine and monitor children’s smartphone use in practice, particularly when devices may belong to their parents or other relatives.

Any prohibition would need to clarify who was responsible, how compliance would be monitored and violations handled, and whether enforcement costs would be proportionate to the expected benefits.

She supported restricting phone use in specific settings and at certain times, such as during school hours, while introducing stronger safeguards for younger children.

Instead of imposing a blanket ban on everyone aged 16 and under, she called for regulations based on age, risk levels, and purposes of use.

Should Vietnam ban children aged 16 and under from using smartphones? - Ảnh 2.

National Assembly deputy Trinh Thi Tu Anh. Photo: Gia Han / Tuoi Tre

Digital platforms must take greater responsibility

Tu Anh said future policies should shift their focus from managing devices to addressing the risks children face online.

Regulations should specify age-appropriate access to social media, online games, and services that could cause addiction or harm children’s development.

Digital service providers should be responsible for age verification, child-protection settings, restrictions on certain interactive features, and controls on inappropriate content.

Platforms should not simply set out terms of use and shift the responsibility for child protection to families.

They should also address design features that encourage prolonged use, such as autoplay, excessive notifications, and algorithms that continuously recommend content to keep users engaged, particularly on children’s accounts.

Schools should establish clear rules on smartphone use during lessons and educational activities, while digital literacy programs should teach children to identify misinformation, avoid online scams and abuse, protect personal data, and develop healthy technology habits.

Tu Anh cautioned against using screen time as the sole measure of the impact of smartphones. One hour spent learning a foreign language or exploring science cannot be equated with an hour spent viewing harmful content or using social media without supervision.

She called for evidence-based measures whose effectiveness could be assessed and adjusted for different age groups, in place of uniform administrative restrictions.

Parents should decide when, why and under what conditions their children can use smartphones, taking into account their ages, maturity, and actual needs.

Younger children should receive direct guidance and supervision, while older children should gradually be given more independence alongside greater responsibility.

Tu Anh also warned against imposing overly broad legal liability or penalizing parents simply for allowing their children to use smartphones.

Instead, responsibility should be shared among families, schools, regulators, and digital service providers.

Expert recommends banning smartphones in schools

Nguyen Dinh Hau, a lecturer at the University of Social Sciences and Humanities under Vietnam National University-Hanoi, said any proposal to completely ban children’s smartphone use required careful study and assessment.

As an initial measure, he recommended considering a ban on smartphone use in learning spaces at elementary and middle schools.

Children in these age groups have not yet developed sufficient skills and knowledge to process information accessed through smart devices, making them more vulnerable to harmful content and its effects on their behavior and psychology, he said.

Hau stressed that this did not mean denying the benefits of smart mobile devices in modern society. Rather, restricting their use at school could help reduce the risks for younger children, who are more vulnerable than older age groups.

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *